Back Yard Peanut Butters

S’Mores

Campfire nostalgia in every bite! 

All the magic of s’mores without the campfire. Chocolate-covered graham crackers, crunchy marshmallow bits (just like Lucky Charms!), and rich cocoa swirled into our creamy natural peanut butter. Pure childhood bliss in a jar.

What’s mixed in: Chocolate-covered graham crackers, crunchy marshmallow bits, cocoa powder

Perfect for: Graham crackers, ice cream topping, or straight from the jar

Everything Bagel

Savory meets nutty in the most unexpected way!

Everything bagel seasoning and crispy bagel chips bring all the flavors you love from your favorite breakfast spot. Sesame seeds, garlic, onion, and poppy seeds create a surprisingly delicious savory twist.

What’s mixed in: Everything bagel seasoning, crispy bagel chips

Perfect for: Everything bagels (obviously!), spread onto dates, topping for cucumber slices, in a sandwich with cream cheese.

Mexican Hot Chocolate

Chocolate meets cinnamon, with a spicy twist! ️

Rich cocoa, warm cinnamon, and a touch of cayenne pepper transform our creamy natural peanut butter into a bold, spicy adventure. Inspired by traditional Mexican hot chocolate with no added sugar and medium heat that slowly builds and hits at the end.

What’s mixed in: Cayenne pepper, semisweet chocolate chips, cinnamon, cocoa powder

Perfect for: Smoothies, topping for vanilla ice cream, or brave souls who eat it straight from the jar

Horchata Chip

Cinnamon vibes with a satisfying crunch! ✨

Inspired by the beloved Mexican drink, our creamy natural peanut butter blends warm cinnamon with crispy puffed rice for a unique texture experience. Creamy, cinnamon-spiced, and surprisingly addictive.

What’s mixed in: Ground cinnamon, puffed brown rice

Perfect for: Apple slices, rice cakes, oatmeal, or yogurt swirls

Dill Pickle

Tangy meets nutty in the most unexpected way!

This savory, tangy spread is perfect for adventurous snackers who love bold flavors. The tangy dill pickle taste with satisfying crunch will surprise and delight.

What’s mixed in: Dill pickle seasoning, pickle-coated peanuts

Perfect for: Topping on cucumber slices, on a cheese board right next to the mustard, dip with pretzel sticks, or paired with cranberry jelly